Ginsburg argues for equal rights, Jewish holidays at Adas Israel

Supreme Court Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg spoke before a sold out audience of 1400 at Adas Israel Congregation in Washington on Thursday. Photo by Dan Schere

Supreme Court Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg has one wish for the Constitution — that the document include a equal rights amendment to guarantee gender equality.

“I take out my pocket constitution and say ‘I have three granddaughters,’” she told a Washington audience of 1,400 people on Feb. 1. “I point to the First Amendment guaranteeing freedom of speech, press, religion. I would like them to see in the Constitution a statement that men and women are persons of equal citizenship stature.”

In a 1 hour and 20-minute conversation with Forward Editor-in-Chief Jane Eisner at Adas Israel Congregation, the 84-year-old Ginsberg was witty and professorial  as she talked about women’s rights, other justices, Jewish and not, and her own future plans.

Ginsburg said that although explicit gender discrimination had largely faded by the 1970s, when the Equal Rights Amendment was passed by the Senate, it still occurred in more discreet ways.

“There was a tendency to tune out when a woman was speaking, because she couldn’t have been saying anything worthwhile,” she said.

Last month, Ginsburg expressed support for the #MeToo movement and revealed that while a student at Cornell University she was propositioned by a chemistry professor who gave her an advance copy of an exam.

“I knew exactly what he wanted in return,” she told NPR’s Nina Totenberg.

When Eisner asked Ginsburg if she had experienced sexism since then, she said, “Not that kind of sexism,” but discrimination it is still an issue.

Eisner told Ginsburg that, according to the Harvard Business Review, the Supreme Court’s female justices are interrupted by their male colleagues three times more than the men interrupt each other. She said that sounded accurate, and recalled an oral argument during which she interrupted Justice Sandra Day O’Connor, leading to a media frenzy.

“The next day in USA Today the headline, was ‘Rude Ruth Interrupts Sandra,’” Ginsburg said.

Ginsburg said she apologized to O’Connor, who said, “Don’t worry, the guys do it all the time.”

Ginsburg said the reporter attended oral arguments the next day and said, “You know, [O’Connor’s] right, but I never noticed it when the men interrupt all the time.”

Ginsburg joked that the real reason she interrupted O’Connor is because her colleague is a slow-talking “laid back gal from the West” and she is a “fast-talking Jewish girl from New York.”

The justice told Eisner that more than once the Court has adjusted for its Jewish justices. There had been no Jewish justice since the 1960s when Ginsburg was appointed. She discovered that the dates on the certificates admitting attorneys to argue cases before the Supreme Court bar read “In the year of our Lord.”

“And he’s not our Lord,” Ginsburg said, referring to Jews and Jesus, respectively.

“I spoke to the chief,” she said. He said the wording was good enough for former Jewish justices Louis Brandeis, Benjamin Cardozo, Felix Frankfurter and Arthur Goldberg.

“It’s not good enough for Ginsburg,” she said. She was able to change the rule.

A year later, Stephen Breyer became the court’s second Jewish justice. She said the two teamed up to ask Chief Justice William Rehnquist to reschedule a case that fell during the High Holidays so that they could celebrate them. Rehnquist obliged.

“The argument that was utterly convincing for the chief was that in an argument, there will inevitably be Jewish lawyers,” she said. “Do you want to take away from them the opportunity to present their case? And that resonated. So now we don’t sit on the High Holy Days.”

Asked how her Judaism has informed her career, the justice drew on the themes of the Jewish diaspora as she discussed how her parents had immigrated to the United States from Europe.

“The sense of being an outsider, of being one of the people had suffered oppression for no sensible reason… it’s the sense of being part of a minority,” she said. “It makes you more empathetic to other people who are outsiders.”

“She really expressed how she interprets the constitution and what it means to be human,” said Patricia Hunt, who teaches an introductory law course at Wakefield High School in Arlington.

Falls Church resident Roz Cohen said Ginsburg was “just as wonderful” as she anticipated, and appreciated her comments on gender discrimination.

“In these times, you think you’ve won all these battles, but the same old issues come around again, so I was glad that she pointed that out,” she said.

Although Ginsburg said she would not discuss any cases before the court, she was willing to weigh in on whether Supreme Court justices should have fixed terms rather than the current life term.

“It is a subject on which I am biased and prejudiced,” she said, eliciting applause from the friendly crowd when said she has no plans to retire from the court.

“As long as I can do the job, I’ll be here.”

[email protected]

Never miss a story.
Sign up for our newsletter.
Email Address


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here