What time is minyan?


On Tuesday July 2 at Mincha (afternoon service) I completed 11 months of saying Kaddish for my mom, Janice Hiller z”l.  Although I will still be in mourning until the end of the month, my obligation to say Kaddish on a daily basis will be completed.

Since her passing, I have attempted to honor her life and her memory by going to shul three times a day to say Kaddish; Shacharit, Mincha and Ma’ariv  (morning, afternoon and evening services) every day. At Beth Sholom Congregation and Talmud Torah, we say Kaddish a lot! Eight times a day to be exact. There are some exceptions but I estimate that during the year of mourning I have said this prayer more than 2,500 times. Although it’s been almost 11 months since she passed away, and the Kaddish is indelibly etched in my brain, I still think about my mom each and every time I recite the prayer. I guess that’s what it is all about.

Eleven months in any calendar is a long time and this year has been one in which I have truly counted the days and the number of places where I have gone to minyan. Every day, every business trip, every vacation required that a synagogue be close by and for me to know what time of day they were davening. At Beth Sholom, morning minyan is either 6:10 on Rosh Chodesh, 6:15 on fast days, 6:20 on Mondays and Thursdays, 8 a.m. on Sundays and federal holidays, sometimes, and 9 a.m. on Shabbat. And Mincha and Ma’ariv are always changing according to the sunset. That moving schedule is the norm in the shuls that I have attended; of course, there are exceptions. No surprise there.

The list of shuls is pretty overwhelming. Aside from the majority of my time which was spent at Beth Sholom, I have also had the opportunity to pray at Chabad in Potomac, Bethesda, and Fairfax; Young Israel in Potomac and Oak Park, Mich., the Woodside shul, the ROC, BECO, the Bethesda Minyan, Beth El of MC, Ohr Kodesh, the Berman Academy, the Yeshiva, CES-JDS, Gesher Jewish Day School, Congregation Olam Tikvah, Agudas Achim, Beth Emeth, Temple Rodef Shalom and at both of Washington Hebrew Congregation’s sites. I have said Kaddish at the Israeli Embassy in D.C. and at the Ronald Reagan Building, and at The Jewish Federation while attending Federation board meetings/events. While visiting my dad I have been to been a Chabad in Lakewood, the Freehold Jewish Center and then there were the Florida shuls: Anshei Shalom and Del Ray Orthodox.


I recently returned from visiting my daughter in Israel where I found minyanim in 18 shuls and yeshivas including one in the ancient shul on top of Masada, one in a hotel at the Dead Sea and one by the beach in Nahariya on Yom Ha’atzmaut. I davened Shacharit in Meah Shearim in a shul where there was a minyan starting every 10 minutes or so and in a haredi shul in Bet Shemesh. There were several minyanim in Israel where I was the only one who was not dressed in black. And EVERYONE was totally warm, friendly and comforting even when we had limited conversation. I even got an aliyah at the Great Synagogue in Jerusalem.

I can’t forget the cruise, when my friends Ari and David and I were on a mission to recruit “congregants” to join us for several minyanim. I think our kabbalat Shabbat on the cruise had people from 10 different countries and five continents in attendance.  And finally I can’t forget the Chabad in Cozumel, Mexico where a special Mincha was convened to accommodate me.

While it has been a very difficult year in many ways it has also been a wonderful experience. As I have celebrated my mom’s life and mourned her passing, I have found tremendous support from the community. I have felt welcomed and have benefited from all the support provided by the regulars who make the minyan. And a special shout out to my friends at Beth Sholom’s daily minyan; thank you for making me part of your family. And of course I would be remiss if I did not thank my own family and my wonderful wife, Kim, who has been supportive of me throughout from the 5:30 a.m. wake up for Shacharit to the 8:25 Mincha/Ma’ariv, and as she asks:

“What time is minyan?” I have a different answer nearly every day.

Finally to my mom, Shayndal bat Rachel, may your memory always be for a blessing for anyone who had the pleasure to know you. While you are missed terribly you will never be forgotten.

It’s late and I need to go, tomorrow is Wednesday; oh and by the way minyan is at 6:30 a.m.

Janice Hiller’s yahrtzeit will be observed on the 24th of Av which is July 31.

Arnie Heller is a member of the board of The Jewish Federation of Greater Washington and past president of Gesher Jewish Day School of Northern Virginia.



Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here